TurkeyOnAStick's art Reviews on Newgrounds

[heyy]

heyy

FYI it doesn't do you any favours if you trace an image and don't say you did, since it gives people a false impression on how much work you have put into the pic.

[Creeper Weekly Color # 3]

Mm.

This is gonna sound exceptionally bitter, 50, but:
High score because it's Minecraft.

That's a real shame, and I'm quite disappointed in the voting public. This pic no way demonstrates or challenges anything that you, Fifty-50, are capable of, apart from you're highlighting towards yellow.

Fifty-50 responds:

Yeah I have agree! I'd expected a lower score since this generally took a small amount of time on it. I apologize to have disappointed you, I'll try my best to make a better picture next time. :) Thanks for reviewing Turkey. Greatly appreciated.

[Madness Day 2011]

Unless somebody submits something epic soon ...

... it's going to be either you are Rhunyc who takes all the moneys.
Aamzing work, both with the original pencil drawing and the painting underneath. You could probably submit your Tricky the Clown by itself, and take a prize for his sheer dynamism.

Some of the foreshortening on Hank's and Tricky's right arm is a bit queer; even though you're covering up the forearm and elbow behind the hands, I feel they look misplaced, and can only be posed like that if they had several extra joints in the shoulder. Also the text in the top left corner: bleuch!

Fifty-50 responds:

Thanks for the crit turkey. :3 I'm sure I'll make it better. I'm just happy I was able to submit something this time.

[Tropic Bikini]

It's a copy.

As Aetolon as said (and linked!) you have copied an existing anime drawing. In future, I would recommend you these unchecked as sketches, and provide a link to your reference in your author's comments.
- One of the art portal moderators

HisInfernalLove responds:

Did not copy =__= I sketched a picture off google and just changed the hair, again it's not original work. I would give credit to the original author if there were so many people saying it's their work. I don't plagiarize or anything of the sort. Thank you and have a nice day

[Fluttershy Adventures]

Brilliant.

Enjoy the fluctuating score, aigis.

[Self-Portrait]

Good. One problem:

This self-portrait looks nothing like me.
Please fix.

J-qb responds:

Well son, you look a little like me and a little like your mama; just like I look a little like your granpa and a little like your grandma.

[Heawbeaw & scrimps]

I FP'd it ...

... cos it's good, you're a good artist who needs more attention, and you haven't been on the FP this year.

Hope you've got something in the pipeline, so I can totally regret my decision.

sucho responds:

b..but.......my other uploads are beeeetttteeerrr *whiiiiiiine* nnneeeeeh

[PokeWIP_2]

ayup

Looks fab.
Hate to be a dork, but how do you handle psychic Pokemon, and why have you chosen not to evolve Scyther?

Kumakun4 responds:

I actually haven't played in years, so this team is zero strategy haha. I just grabbed my old Pokémon Yellow Player's Guide and went with what looked good.
Machamp looked like good anatomy practice and Hitmonlee is there due to a recent Kung Fu craving.
I also had no idea Scyther could evolve.

[Technological Seduction]

Technological Suctioned

Whilst a couple of reviewers has mentioned the similarities with greek mythology, I want to say this reminded me of Waterhouse's "Hylas and the Nymphs". That's not to say it's unoriginal. On the contrary, I find the piece a whole lot stronger by linking it with classical stories/paintings.

Loving the watercolours and the gouache; they're perfect for this image.

[Robot]

Tobor

Great highlights, great rendering, great perspective.
I hope you're proud of yourself.

I've deducted a point because you haven't yet tagged this robotday2011, and that's just silly for something of this standard.

Please remedy this.

J-qb responds:

remedy-d